Posted by Jason | Posted in Economics, Foreign Policy | Posted on 07-10-2010
Timothy is apparently asking China to make it even harder on Americans. He’s calling on China to increase the value of the Yaun, which would make Chinese products more expensive for Americans. Doesn’t he realize this is what has helped Americans live the standard of living they currently do. With the Fed destroying the value of the dollar, if China increases the value of their currency, working class and poor Americans will be in for a shock when they hit the local Walmart.
WASHINGTON—The U.S. and China stepped up their confrontation over the valuation of Beijing’s currency, prompted by fears that competing foreign-exchange policies could hamper the global economic recovery.
First, let’s quit worrying about the so called global recovery and instead worry about what’s right for the American public. If China wants to devalue their currency, it only helps Americans. Who is Geithner really worrying about?
In a surprisingly blunt speech, U.S. Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner took China to task for maintaining what the U.S. considers a deliberately undervalued exchange rate aimed at helping China’s export industries.
By undervaluing their exchange, Americans can get products for less than they would otherwise. With the savings, Americans can acquire even more products that they would have otherwise been unable to afford had China not undervalued their exchange rate. If anyone should be complaining about this, it should be the Chinese workers as their buying power is being eaten away.
“When large economies with undervalued exchange rates act to keep the currency from appreciating, that encourages other countries to do the same,” said Mr. Geithner, using language that referred directly to China, in an address at the Brookings Institution, a Washington think tank. “This sets off a dangerous dynamic” as nations compete to keep their currencies undervalued.
It encourages other countries to do the same because their leaders are as intelligent as a bunch of monkeys. It sounds more like the old monkey see monkey do than it sounds like intelligent economic policy. Geithner is basically saying “Look China is taxing their citizens wealth away with inflation. We better do the same thing.” Of course, the Fed does plenty of this already.
In Brussels, before Mr. Geithner spoke, Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao asked European Union business and political leaders to tone down their attacks on Beijing. “If the yuan is not stable, it will bring disaster to China and the world,” he said. “If we increase the yuan by 20% or 40%, as some people are calling for, many of our factories will shut down and society will be in turmoil.”
What this basically means is if China did as the other idiotic leaders called on them to do, prices of Chinese goods would go up by 20% to 40%. How’s that inflation sound to you? Because Americans would buy less of their goods, Chinese workers would also be harmed with layoffs.
The broadsides came as leaders prepare to gather in Washington for meetings at the International Monetary Fund, followed by two sessions of the Group of 20 industrialized and developing nations. The increasingly exasperated rhetoric suggests participants are losing patience with a multilateral approach to currency issues.
Indeed, Mr. Geithner warned China that the U.S. support for a bigger role for Beijing in the IMF depends on Beijing showing “more progress” in pursuing “market-oriented exchange-rate policies.” Fred Bergsten, director of the Peterson Institute for International Economics said that U.S. was saying to Beijing, “We’ll only support your game if you play by the rules.”
Geithner playing the ugly American. Go figure. Unfortunately, China holds all the cards and they know it. Wait it gets better.
To the U.S., China is pursuing a mercantilist strategy that favors its industries at the expense of competitors in the U.S., Europe and Asia. China sees itself as pursuing its national interest and a strategy that has turned the country from an impoverished also-ran into a powerhouse.
You got that. China is mercantilist, but the US is what? We put tariffs on steel why? We put tariffs on sugar why? We subsidize our farmers why? You get the point.
Mr. Geithner hasn’t named a target for Chinese currency appreciation that the U.S. would find satisfactory. But he has often spoken favorably of the 20% rise in the yuan from 2006 to 2008.
Now could you imagine having a 20% rise in the dollar? Aren’t we always told deflation is so horrible. A little inflation is good, but you never want deflation. Well what the hell do they think a 20% rise in the yaun valuation will bring for the Chinese?
No worries though. Geithner has a solution. Cartels.
In his speech, Mr. Geithner suggested countries with undervalued currencies could cooperate on kind of joint currency appreciation. In that way, China need not worry that Asian competitors such as Malaysia and Vietnam will gain an edge if the yuan rises in value.
I thought Cartels were bad. Oh, I forgot. Many things that are bad for individuals and private business are righteous when the government does them.